They Told Us What Censorship Looks Like. We Should Listen.
Writers across genres reveal how censorship restricts ideas, controls information, silences lived experiences, and threatens our fundamental freedom to read.

There is a reason dystopian novels so often begin with control over information. Burn the books. Rewrite the history. Narrow the vocabulary. Decide which stories are dangerous. Convince people that restricting information will protect them. And eventually, teach people to censor themselves.
These ideas can feel comfortably fictional when we encounter them in novels like Fahrenheit 451, 1984, and The Handmaid's Tale. But writers of memoir and nonfiction have documented the same impulses outside the pages of dystopian fiction for centuries.
During Banned Books Week, it is worth listening to what these writers have been telling us. Because censorship is rarely only about one book. It’s about who gets to speak, whose experiences are considered acceptable, what information people are permitted to encounter, and ultimately who gets to decide.
Restrict Knowledge, Maintain Power
In his 1845 memoir Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, Frederick Douglass recounts how Sophia Auld began teaching him to read when he was enslaved as a child. Her husband, Hugh Auld, discovered what she was doing and immediately ordered her to stop. Teaching an enslaved person to read, Auld told his wife, was both "unlawful" and "unsafe." He explained that education would make Douglass "unmanageable" and "forever unfit him to be a slave."
Douglass understood immediately what he had inadvertently been taught: "From that moment, I understood the pathway from slavery to freedom." The person attempting to keep him illiterate had revealed precisely why literacy mattered.
Douglass's experience provides one of American history's clearest demonstrations of the relationship between access to information and power. Enslaved people weren't prohibited from learning to read because books themselves posed a physical threat. Literacy was dangerous to enslavers because reading gave enslaved people access to ideas, communication, knowledge, and possibilities beyond the world their enslavers constructed for them. The restriction was a means of control.
Nearly two centuries later, the circumstances are obviously profoundly different. But the underlying lesson about information remains valuable: when evaluating an attempt to restrict access to ideas, we should ask not only What information is being restricted? but also Who gains greater control when other people cannot access it?
Control the Words, Control the Conversation
George Orwell explored another form of information control in 1984. The government of Oceania does not merely prohibit certain ideas. It works to eliminate the language necessary to express them. Newspeak systematically shrinks vocabulary so that eventually certain thoughts become difficult, even impossible, to articulate. As Syme explains, the objective is to make thoughtcrime "literally impossible, because there will be no words in which to express it." The warning reaches beyond governments literally inventing new languages.
Controlling language can mean deciding that certain subjects cannot be discussed. It can mean labeling accurate descriptions of people's lives inappropriate. It can mean removing the vocabulary young people need to understand racism, sexuality, abuse, gender, mental health, or their own bodies. And it can mean creating rules so vague that teachers, librarians, and writers begin avoiding subjects simply because they aren't certain where the invisible line lies.
That last form of censorship is particularly effective because eventually no one needs to explicitly order the silence. People learn to silence themselves. PEN America has documented authors describing exactly that chilling effect amid today's book bans, with some writers reporting concerns that potential backlash could influence what they create in the future. During the 2025–26 school year alone, school book bans affected the works of more than 4,000 authors, illustrators, and translators, the highest number PEN America has recorded in a single school year. The censorship of today's book can influence the writing of tomorrow's.
Make People Afraid of the Book
Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 gives us perhaps the most recognizable image of literary censorship: firefighters burning books. But Bradbury's world contains a more complicated warning than "government burns books." The society has grown suspicious of discomfort itself. Books contain conflicting ideas. They make people question things. They offend. They disturb. They require readers to encounter experiences and perspectives that may challenge what they already believe.
So the culture gradually decides it is easier not to encounter them at all. Captain Beatty tells Montag that a book is a "loaded gun in the house next door." Think about that metaphor. The book becomes the threat. Not ignorance. Not the suppression of speech. Not the person demanding that nobody else be permitted to read something. The book becomes dangerous.
That framing should sound familiar to anyone following contemporary book challenges. Books are routinely described as dangerous or harmful based on individual passages, images, or subjects. Entire works are reduced to a handful of excerpts. The question shifts from whether a particular book has literary, educational, historical, or personal value to whether someone can find something inside it that makes them uncomfortable.
And increasingly, nonfiction is caught in that net. PEN America found that 29 percent of unique titles banned during the 2024–25 school year were nonfiction. More than 1,100 unique nonfiction titles disappeared from school shelves, including history, health information, biographies, and memoirs. That matters because removing nonfiction does not simply limit access to stories. It limits access to facts, history, testimony, and lived experience.
Silence the Person Telling the Story
Memoir poses a particular problem for censorship because it says: This happened to me. A fictional character can be dismissed as invented. A memoirist presents their own life as evidence. As Frederick Douglass demonstrated in his memoir, firsthand accounts can expose systems of oppression in ways that are difficult to dismiss or deny. That helps explain why memoirs dealing with racism, the Holocaust, sexual violence, religious trauma, gender, and LGBTQ+ experiences repeatedly appear in challenges.
Elie Wiesel's Night has been among the nonfiction works removed from school access during the current censorship movement. Maya Angelou's I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings has faced challenges for decades. Contemporary memoirs including George M. Johnson's All Boys Aren't Blue have become frequent targets.
Their experiences are very different, but the act of restricting memoir carries an especially troubling message: You may have lived this, but we don't want other people to hear about it.
A memoir allows someone else to testify. It also allows a reader to discover that an experience they thought was theirs alone has happened to someone else. That connection is powerful. Which is precisely why silencing it can be powerful too.
"Don't Let the Bastards Grind You Down"
Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale imagines a society in which women lose far more than access to books. They lose control over money, work, movement, their bodies, and even their names. Reading itself becomes forbidden to most women.
Yet Offred secretly treasures words. Scrabble becomes illicit. Reading a message becomes an act of resistance. Language represents access to a self that exists beyond what the state has decided she is allowed to be.
One phrase secretly scratched into a closet becomes especially important to her: "Nolite te bastardes carborundorum." Don't let the bastards grind you down. The message survives because someone wrote it and someone else found it.
That is what books do. They allow one human being to leave something behind for another: a warning, an experience, a fact, a question, a possibility, a reassurance that someone else has felt what you feel.
The Warnings Are Still on the Shelves, If We Let Them Stay There
This Banned Books Week, the scale of censorship remains staggering. The American Library Association recorded 4,235 unique titles challenged in 2025, the second-highest number it has ever documented. Ninety-two percent of challenges came from pressure groups, government officials, and other decision-makers, while fewer than 3 percent originated with individual parents.
PEN America reports that more than 34,000 school book bans have occurred since 2021. And the targets tell us something. Books about race. Books about LGBTQ+ people. Books about sexual violence. History books. Health books. Memoirs. Dystopian novels. Books that help readers name things. Books that tell readers what happened. Books that imagine what could happen. Books that let people whose experiences have historically been marginalized say, I was here. This happened. This is my story.
The writers quoted here lived in different centuries and wrote under radically different circumstances. We should not flatten those histories or pretend every restriction on a school-library book is equivalent to the oppression Douglass survived or the authoritarian governments imagined by Orwell and Atwood.
But we should pay attention to the principle connecting their work. Power and information have always been intertwined. That is why the freedom to read matters. A free society does not require every reader to approve of every book. It does not require every parent to choose every book for their child.
It requires something much simpler and much harder: The humility to recognize that we do not get to make that choice for everyone else. This Banned Books Week, read the books people have tried to silence. They may have something important to tell us.